It's interesting that for someone who reads other's blogs, I have never had one set up for myself. I think it must be similar to the Twitter account I have set up - I wait for the one really super inspired post to hit a home run, as opposed to the string of base hits that is life!
This blog is set up for Royal Roads University's Instructional Skills Workshop (ISWO) to allow for reflections on what I'm learning and to discuss whatever happens to come to mind. One thought that I had was that the most effective online experiences I've had have been fully interactive and not just one-way. A lot of the material that I discuss can be dry or hard to visualize, particularly if the learner isn't inclined towards numbers.
The scenario was such: I was teaching a 1 hour finance session using Elluminate and there wasn't one bit of interaction for the first half hour. The class was absolutely boring for them - I could feel myself becoming less and less comfortable. I began to rush. My voice got dry and high-pitched. I began to wonder how I was going to go through 10 more sessions like this. As we hit the half hour mark, I had gone through all my slides and I asked, "are there any questions?" One fellow wanted to talk about the US debt crisis, one wanted to talk about the Canadian dollar, and one asked "can we see the slides again, only slowly and with detail?" At that moment I realized that I hadn't asked one question of the class, checked for comprehension, or solicited any meaningful feedback along the way to see whether they were understanding what was going on.
I went back and went through the slides again (which were heavy on calculations) and didn't treat it like a race. I made use of the text box on the side for answers to be posted in, used checkmarks and X's to determine whether I should stop and clarify or whether it was fine to move on, and asked the learners who got the answers right to explain (vocally) how they came up with their answers as they might phrase their thought process in a manner more consistent with the other learners. Essentially I went back to the drawing board after spending a half hour delivering a soliloquy and was rewarded with feedback on how I was doing.
The learning in this case was two way: I learned the first approach I took (to rush with no feedback) was ineffective and that having interaction is what makes teaching satisfying to me; secondly, the learner feedback confirmed that the first session was ineffective for them as well, and that for complex material they want the opportunity to have questions addressed (similar to F2F). I recognize that online learning is largely self-directed, but I want to ensure I have used strategies and tools to make the process enjoyable for everyone. Not easy, but enjoyable!
Hi Stephen,
ReplyDeleteSounds like you're learning from your experience!
There has been some interesting conversations in the education world recently about the "flipped" or "backwards" classroom, for example:
http://thejournal.com/Articles/2011/02/02/The-Backwards-Class.aspx?Page=1
I wonder if something like that might work in your situation. If you gave your students the opportunity to review the slides in advance of your synchronous session, then what happens during the session might be more interactive from the get-go. Worth a try?
What an insightful story, Stephen. Elluminate can be a very isolating experience if you do not build in interaction. Unlike the f2f classroom you don't have any visual clues from your audience (unless you have them on video). It can seem like your voice is just going out into the ether and you don't know if anyone is listening, much less learning! By asking questions and using the interactive tools built into Elluminate you were able to redirect your energies into making it a positive experience for you and your students.
ReplyDeleteHi Elizabeth,
ReplyDeleteThat is a very interesting link and your suggestions are equally thoughtful. The texts I have been using have PowerPoints on the website, but I'm not sure that the learners have been inclined to use them. What I have observed is that each were interested in receiving the PowerPoints I used during the Elluminate sessions. Further, they were always interested in watching the recordings of the "Live Hours", which ties in with the ideas in the "backwards classroom".
I did find that the interaction of going through questions provided a lot of the "a-ha" moments for the learners; I don't think this would consistently be the case if we were relying exclusively on Moodle posts. With multi-step, multi-variable problems using either functions in Excel or on financial calculators where there are a lot of opportunities to enter a wrong variable.
Thanks for the suggestions!
Always fun to share ideas! I hope the ISWO folks are all reading each other's blogs.
ReplyDeleteBode's ISWO blog at
http://bfagbamiye.blogspot.com/
points to some research that might be useful to you (and others) in ISWO
First blogger in our ISWO training, congratulations! And I have to say that you did a very good start... Well done!
ReplyDelete